Frozen for six weeks, now back on: Fathermoh and Harry Craze win round in Sh87 million fight with US label as High Court faults it for hiding key facts
For six weeks, two of gengetone's best-known voices could not move an inch in their battle for their own songs. Now the High Court has cleared the road, lifting orders that had frozen the cases Fathermoh and Harry Craze filed against their former label, the US-based Black Market Records.
In a ruling delivered on November 9 and reported by KBC, Nation and TV47 this week, the court set aside orders issued on September 29 that had stopped the Copyright Tribunal from hearing the two disputes. It also struck out the label's application to have the matters moved to the High Court, and ordered Black Market Records LLC and its representative, Cedric Singleton, to pay the musicians' costs.
Nation and TV47 put the value of Fathermoh's claim at Sh87 million.
What the court found
The label went to the High Court arguing that the tribunal had no power to handle the disputes, and it won temporary orders in September without the musicians being heard.
Fathermoh, whose real name is Moses Otieno Ojwang, and Harry Craze, born Harry Otieno Adoyo, then asked the court to reverse the freeze. They said the label had not told the judge about notices of appeal lodged on September 11 against tribunal decisions, or about earlier commercial suits between the parties that had been withdrawn or struck out.
According to KBC's account of the ruling, the judge agreed that the omissions were material and held that, had the information been disclosed, the court would not have granted the orders in the first place.
The court also noted that:
- the label had not obtained an exemption allowing it to skip the tribunal and go straight to judicial review
- the Copyright Tribunal has a statutory mandate under Section 48 of the Copyright Act to hear disputes on ownership and royalties
- a required verifying affidavit had not been filed, and the company had not shown it had legal capacity to bring the case
The musicians had cited California corporate records which they said showed an entity registered in 1999 had been suspended. The label disputed this. In an affidavit sworn by its manager, it maintained it was operational and in good standing, saying it moved its main operations to Florida in 2015.
How the dispute began
The row traces back to an agreement dated November 9, 2019, and to the songs made under it. Harry Craze's claim, filed on May 11 this year, covers works including "Matopare", "Luku Ni Pyam" and "Diglo". Fathermoh also went to the tribunal in May, accusing the label of unlawfully monetising his music and denying him control of his catalogue, TV47 reported.
On May 22, the tribunal issued interim orders barring the label and related parties from monetising or claiming ownership of the artistes' works, and from interfering with their concerts and promotional campaigns, pending a full hearing, according to The Star.
What happens next
The ruling is a procedural win, not the final whistle. The High Court did not decide who owns the disputed songs or whether the musicians are owed money. Those questions go back to the Copyright Tribunal, which has been directed to proceed with both cases.
For Kenyan artistes watching from the sidelines, the case is being followed as a test of how far the tribunal can go in policing recording deals signed with foreign labels. Black Market Records has contested the musicians' claims, and the allegations against it remain untested until the tribunal hears the evidence.
Photos: Fathermoh and Harry Craze, courtesy via Citizen Digital. Thumbnail design: HAMASTA MEDIA.
More in Entertainment
See all
ONAGI galla night at Nairobi this November

GTA VI Hype Builds Ahead Of Release As 12 Million Pre-Order Claim Circulates

'Those who said it was repossessed are in for a shock': Kenyan Prince unloads his Lamborghini in Mombasa, nearly hits a bystander and claims a Sh1 billion fortune

'Leo sitakubali': Musa Jakadalla walks off the Luo Festival stage over the sound, blames 'sabotage', and even Jalang'o cannot bring him back

'Your music and legacy will live on': Ohangla singer Onyango Jasuba dies in Sindo as the Luo Festival weekend gets under way







Global Community Remarks
0