HRW warns European plan for Rwanda deportation hub risks breaching international law
Human Rights Watch (HRW) has accused five European countries of shirking their responsibilities by planning to send rejected asylum seekers to a deportation centre in Rwanda, according to Africanews.
Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands announced on Monday that they are setting up what they called a "migrant hub" in the East African country. Asylum seekers whose applications have failed could be transferred there from next year.
The international rights group argues that the European governments involved have no way of guaranteeing that the migrants' rights will be protected once they arrive in Rwanda. In its view, this would place the countries in breach of their obligations under international law.
Risks of abuse
HRW listed several dangers it says those transferred could face. These include:
- torture;
- ill-treatment;
- arbitrary detention;
- other forms of abuse.
The organisation also pointed to its own experience with Rwandan authorities. In 2024, one of its researchers was refused entry to the country at a time when the United Kingdom was pursuing a similar scheme to relocate asylum seekers there.
Concerns over US deportees
HRW further raised questions about people already sent to Rwanda from outside Africa. The United States deported about 20 people to the country over the past year, the group said, but little has emerged about where they are, the conditions in which they are living or how they are faring.
That lack of information, the rights group suggests, highlights how difficult it is to monitor the treatment of people once they are moved beyond the jurisdiction of the countries that sent them.
Europe's tougher migration stance
The plan forms part of a wider push within the European Union. For years, the bloc has been working to tighten its migration rules, cut the number of people arriving to seek asylum and step up the removal of migrants who are not entitled to remain.
Transferring people to centres outside Europe has become a central element of that strategy, according to Africanews. The five-nation arrangement with Rwanda is one of the clearest examples of governments seeking to process or hold failed asylum seekers away from European soil.
Supporters of such offshore arrangements see them as a way to make deportations work and discourage irregular migration. Rights groups such as HRW, however, insist that moving the problem to another country does not remove Europe's legal duties towards the people concerned.
Echoes of the UK scheme
The announcement revives a debate that dominated discussions on migration and Africa during the UK's attempt to send asylum seekers to Rwanda. That earlier scheme faced strong legal challenges and criticism from rights organisations before it was abandoned.
The latest plan is expected to draw similar scrutiny as details emerge about how the hub would operate, who would oversee it and what safeguards would be put in place for those sent there.
Neither the five European governments nor Rwandan authorities were quoted in the Africanews report responding to HRW's criticism.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Africanews. Read the original report. Photo: Africanews.
More in International
See all
Ukraine reportedly hits Krasnodar oil refineries a day after Kerch bridge strike

Family seeks embassy help as Kenyan man goes missing in freezing Belarus forest

First MINURSO contingent leaves Laayoune as UN mission begins phased withdrawal

Ghana defends $60m presidential jet as critics cite cost-of-living strain

Xi says China and Russia should lead push for multipolar world at APEC summit







Global Community Remarks
0