The Court of Appeal has barred former employees of the defunct National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF) from pursuing exit packages estimated at Sh19.8 billion until a government appeal against a ruling that awarded them redundancy benefits is heard and determined, according to Business Daily.

A bench of Justices Wanjiru Karanja, Lydia Achode and Weldon Korir found that the Public Service Commission (PSC) had raised arguable questions on how the law governing the switch from NHIF to the Social Health Authority (SHA) should be interpreted.

The judges, however, declined to touch the salaries of the affected workers, ruling that a separate consent order protecting their existing pay remains binding.

How the dispute arose

NHIF was wound up under the Social Health Insurance Act, 2023, and replaced by SHA. Under the transition, staff could compete for jobs at the new authority, accept redeployment to other government departments, or retire under the relevant pension arrangements.

At the centre of the case was whether those who chose to retire because of the restructuring were entitled to redundancy or severance pay, and whether staff who moved to SHA could keep their previous salaries and benefits.

On July 29, 2025, the Employment and Labour Relations Court held that the winding-up amounted to redundancy. It awarded exit packages to retiring staff and directed SHA to maintain the pay and benefits of transferred employees.

Government's case

The PSC appealed, arguing that voluntary retirement under the health insurance law is not the same as redundancy under the Employment Act. It also contested the finding that SHA, as a separate legal entity, automatically took on NHIF employees' former terms of service.

In a sworn statement, PSC secretary and chief executive Paul Famba said 34 of 215 redeployed workers had demanded exit payments following an interim SHA audit. He said the employees' lawyers wrote on August 6, 2025, asking for a formula to calculate the packages.

The commission warned that any money paid out might be hard to recover if its appeal succeeded, and that the matter could affect plans to restructure about 90 state corporations. It argued the workers were still in public service and could be paid arrears should the appeal fail.

SHA chief executive Mercy Mwangangi backed the application, saying the 2023 law made no provision for exit packages and that the authority had power to set its own terms of employment. She put the cost at about Sh20 billion and said paying it could disrupt the authority's operations and hiring. SHA had advertised 64 senior management positions that August.

Workers push back

The former employees, through former NHIF deputy branch manager Angela Kiloko Mutuku, opposed the suspension. They argued the government could recover any payments if it won, while withholding them would cause hardship.

Ms Mutuku told the court that staff redeployed to SHA and various ministries were being offered much lower salaries than before, despite a July 23, 2025 consent judgment protecting their pay. Their lawyer said the exit package framework was contained in a July 2024 Transition Committee report prepared by the PSC.

A Chief State Counsel representing SHA and the Attorney-General argued that the lower court had placed too much weight on an advisory committee's report.

The ruling

The judges found the appeal arguable on questions of statutory interpretation and labour rights, but said the PSC had not shown the appeal would be rendered useless without a full suspension of the judgment.

"An appeal is not rendered nugatory simply because its execution involves a substantial sum of public funds," the judges said.

They nonetheless noted that the unbudgeted Sh19.8 billion bill was significant and could cause hardship to government operations, and issued an injunction stopping the former workers from demanding the packages pending the appeal.

The substantive appeal will decide whether voluntary retirement during the transition amounted to redundancy.

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Business Daily. Read the original report. Photo: Business Daily.