Employers who accuse workers of deserting their jobs cannot rely on an attendance register alone to justify dismissal, the Employment and Labour Relations Court has ruled.

In a judgment seen by Kenyans.co.ke, Justice Nelson Abuodha held that an employer alleging that a worker has abandoned duty must first try to find out where the employee is, ask for an explanation and start a proper disciplinary process, including issuing a notice to show cause.

The judge dismissed an appeal by a company and upheld a lower court's finding that it had unfairly terminated a former employee.

What the court said

According to the court documents, a dismissal for absconding must be backed by evidence that the employer made a reasonable attempt to contact the worker and issued a show cause letter asking why their services should not be terminated.

The court stated that such dismissal "must be preceded by evidence showing that reasonable attempt was made to contact" the employee concerned.

Background to the dispute

The company had based its case on an attendance register covering the period between March 19 and April 3, 2021. The record showed the employee signed in on March 19 and 20, after which he was marked absent.

The worker, however, told the court that he had been dismissed verbally. He said he was told to go home because there was no work for him.

The employer denied sacking him, insisting that he had walked away from his job without permission or a valid reason. It held to that position throughout a subsequent dispute before the Labour Office.

Gaps in the employer's case

Justice Abuodha found that the company produced no evidence showing it had reached out to the employee once he stopped reporting to work, or that it had asked him to account for his absence.

The judge further observed that correspondence exchanged months later between the company, the Labour Office and the parties' lawyers did not prove that the employer had made reasonable efforts to contact the worker when his absence first began.

The court also noted that the company had not commenced disciplinary proceedings against the employee as required under Section 41 of the Employment Act, even though it relied on his alleged absence as the basis of its defence.

Compensation upheld

Having dismissed the appeal, the court upheld an award of Ksh138,234, equivalent to six months' salary, as compensation for unfair termination.

The employee is also entitled to one month's salary in lieu of notice. The company was further ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

What the ruling means

The decision signals that employers must go beyond simply recording a worker's absence before taking action against them. Firms are expected to show they tried to reach the employee, sought an explanation and followed the procedure set out in law.

At the same time, according to Kenyans.co.ke, the ruling places an obligation on workers to explain any unaccounted absence and to respond when asked to return to work.

Key steps the court expects of an employer before dismissing a worker for absconding include:

  • Making reasonable attempts to establish the employee's whereabouts
  • Requesting an explanation for the absence
  • Issuing a notice to show cause why the employee should not be dismissed
  • Initiating disciplinary proceedings in line with Section 41 of the Employment Act

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Kenyans.co.ke. Read the original report. Photo: Kenyans.co.ke.