One toilet for 42 girls and 3,123 learners paid twice: Auditor General exposes how counties are failing nursery pupils and needy students
Small children queueing for a single toilet, some of them soiling themselves before their turn comes, and learners crammed into classrooms with leaking roofs and cracked walls. That is the picture of early childhood education painted by Auditor General Nancy Gathungu in new performance audits of county governments.
The reports, reported on Tuesday by The Star and The Eastleigh Voice, also question how counties pick the needy learners who receive bursaries, how the money is awarded and whether anyone can account for it.
Nakuru: crowded, unsafe nursery classrooms
Pre-primary education (ECDE) is one of the functions the Constitution assigns to counties. In Nakuru, the audit found that only 404 of 1,062 ECDE centres met the recommended standard of 25 learners per classroom, leading to congestion and little one-on-one time between teachers and children.
- 573 schools (54 per cent) had no toilets dedicated to boys, and 584 (55 per cent) had none set aside for girls.
- Where separate latrines existed, there was one for every 41 boys and one for every 42 girls, against recommended ratios of 1:30 for boys and 1:10 for girls.
- None of 18 sampled schools had disability-friendly latrines, and five had openings wider than the recommended 20cm by 15cm, a risk of children falling in.
- 424 schools (40 per cent) lacked adequate furniture, and 57 per cent did not meet the ratio of one teacher to 25 learners.
The county employed 847 ECDE teachers, while school Boards of Management hired 1,383, about 62 per cent of the workforce. That forced schools to charge parents fees to pay them, shifting the cost of what should be free education onto households. The audit blamed the hiring of unregistered teachers on weak oversight by the county and school boards.
Murang'a, which built 161 classrooms and rehabilitated 327 ECDE centres, was found to face similar challenges.
Narok: bursaries without paperwork
The bursary findings are just as stark. In Narok, 201 of 202 sampled applications were incomplete and lacked approval by the county executive committee, and only 59 had the required supporting documents.
- 3,123 learners received multiple bursaries worth Sh66.2 million.
- 104 beneficiaries received a total of Sh241,611 above their approved school fees.
- Sh65.1 million was allocated in 2023-24 to the governor's office and special-interest individuals without evidence of a transparent selection process.
- Schools had not acknowledged receipt of Sh329.7 million, or 91.7 per cent, of the Sh359.7 million disbursed that year.
Meanwhile, about 159,922 beneficiaries got an average of Sh8,400 each over four years, covering only 21 per cent of their approved fees. The audit warned that needy students with large fee arrears risked dropping out.
Kirinyaga: small sums, no vetting
In Kirinyaga, 95 of 197 sampled applications lacked complete supporting documents and 91 were improperly filled. Applicants received between Sh1,700 and Sh3,500 on average, with no regard to how poor they actually were.
"Needy and deserving students were not adequately identified and risked missing out on bursaries and scholarships," the audit concluded.
The reports are likely to land before county assemblies and Parliament's oversight committees, where governors' administrations will be expected to explain the gaps.
Photos: The Eastleigh Voice / Parliament of Kenya (Auditor General Nancy Gathungu); The Star (ECDE learners). Thumbnail design: HAMASTA MEDIA.
More in Education
See all
Bandits, early marriage and poverty keep millions of Nigerian children out of school

Makini Schools to spend Sh600m expanding Runda campus as premium demand grows

TSC names Cheptumo Ayabei as new Secretary and CEO after months-long search

Homa Bay KCSE candidate dies days after allegedly drinking ethanol in school lab

Master's now or work first? A Kenyan graduate's guide to HELB postgraduate funding and the big international scholarships







Global Community Remarks
0