The herders who came across him at dawn near Sololo thought he was a refugee fleeing the fighting across the border in Ethiopia. He was in fact Abshir Ahmedsadak Abdi, the Nairobi lawyer whose disappearance had sent advocates into the streets and police chiefs into court.

A day after he was found in Marsabit County, hundreds of kilometres from where he was taken, Mr Abdi walked into the Milimani High Court in Nairobi on Friday, 13 November, wearing a face mask and accompanied by relatives. With him was Ayub Mohamud Maalim, who vanished around the same time and was found the same morning.

What the court ordered

Justice Alexander Muteti, who has been hearing a habeas corpus application filed by the family, did not close the file. According to The Standard and other court reports, he issued interim orders that:

  • bar police and other State agencies from arresting, detaining or charging the two men for now;
  • require investigators who want to question them to summon them through their lawyers;
  • set 23 November for a ruling on whether the case continues now that both men are free.

The State argued that habeas corpus had served its purpose once the men resurfaced. The family and the Law Society of Kenya (LSK) want the court to go further and establish who held them, where and on whose orders.

'Dumped in a conflict zone'

Senior Counsel Eric Theuri, leading the family's legal team, asked the judge to hear directly from the two men. "These victims were dumped in a zone where there is conflict on the Ethiopian side so that their abductors cannot be blamed," he told the court, as reported by Dawan Africa. Citizen Digital reported that Mr Abdi had been treated for minor injuries and was in pain after the ordeal and the long road journey back.

Mr Abdi was seized in the early hours of 1 November on Muchai Road, off Ngong Road. CCTV footage played in court shows his car being chased before it runs into a drainage channel, after which he is bundled into a dark SUV by armed, masked men. His brother, Zakaria Abdi, told the court he believed State security officers were involved and linked the abduction to a criminal case at the Makadara Law Courts in which the lawyer is a witness.

What the police say

The National Police Service has denied holding either man. In a statement, spokesperson Muchiri Nyaga said the two were found by members of the public at Rawana and Uran shopping centres on 12 November and escorted to Sololo Police Station, where they recorded statements.

The service said it was "committed to conducting a thorough, impartial and expeditious evidence-led investigation". Its lawyer, Senior Counsel Paul Nyamondi, told the court that investigators were working to bring the abductors to book.

Citizen Digital also reported that Anti-Terrorism Police Unit officers had earlier told the court Mr Abdi was himself under investigation, a claim his lawyers want the judge to examine.

Why it matters

LSK President Charles Kanjama has said the society is troubled by "what appears to be abduction squads" and wants accountability to extend to "those who provide them with resources, issue instructions, or have knowledge of what is happening but remain silent".

No arrests over the abduction have been announced. The ruling on 23 November will decide whether a judge keeps asking who took the two men, or whether that question is left to the police alone.

Photos: The Standard (portrait of Abshir Abdi); Dawan Africa (Abdi at the Milimani High Court, 13 November). Thumbnail design: HAMASTA MEDIA.