A patient walked into an examination room at a Nairobi healthcare facility, noticed CCTV cameras and complained that her privacy had been violated. The Data Commissioner agreed and ordered the business to pay her Sh1.25 million. The High Court has now set that award aside, and its reasoning could affect almost every compensation order Kenya's privacy watchdog has issued.

Justice Francis Andayi ruled that the Data Protection Act gives the Office of the Data Protection Commissioner (ODPC) power to investigate, issue enforcement notices and impose penalties, but does not expressly give it power to decide how much a complainant should be paid, Business Daily and TechTrendsKE reported on Sunday.

A right to compensation, but who decides?

At the centre of the case is Section 65 of the Act, which gives anyone harmed by a data breach the right to compensation from the company responsible. The judge said the section does not say the Commissioner is the one who decides whether harm happened or how much it is worth.

Compensation orders come from Regulation 14(3)(e) of the rules made under the Act. Justice Andayi said a government agency can use only the powers Parliament clearly gave it, and cannot gain a major new power just because a regulation appears to provide one.

He was also troubled by how the award was made. The ODPC investigated the complaint and then ordered payment without a hearing at which both sides could test the evidence.

"Even if a hearing were to be conducted, I again doubt that it would be by the same Data Commissioner to be the one investigating, then prosecuting it and then deciding. That would be against all the rules of natural justice," the judge said.

What it does and does not change

  • The court did not decide whether the patient's privacy was breached. That question goes back to the ODPC.
  • The judge did not strike down Regulation 14(3)(e) or cancel earlier awards. He said that needs a separate judicial review or constitutional petition in which the Attorney-General can take part.
  • The right to seek compensation under Section 65 still stands. What is now in doubt is whether the ODPC is the right body to assess it.

The patient, identified only as GW, and the Data Commissioner had argued that the Act and the regulations together allowed compensation orders, and they relied on earlier High Court decisions. Justice Andayi said those decisions had not examined whether the regulation went beyond what the Act allows.

Millions in past awards now exposed

The ruling matters because compensation has become a major part of the regulator's work. TechTrendsKE reports that more than Sh30 million was paid to individuals in 2025. Past orders include Sh900,000 against Platinum Credit for marketing messages sent after a customer objected, and Sh500,000 against Moja Expressway for using a former employee's photo without consent.

Business Daily says companies facing such orders now have fresh grounds to challenge them. The ruling also lands as Immaculate Kassait, Kenya's first Data Commissioner, prepares to leave office after six years, so her successor will inherit an open question about one of the office's most visible powers.

Photos: TechTrendsKE (Data Commissioner Immaculate Kassait). Thumbnail design: HAMASTA MEDIA.