The morning began with anti-riot police at the gates of the Kilifi Law Courts and dozens of human rights defenders locked outside. By the end of the day the same supporters were cheering inside a packed courtroom: environmental activist David Katana would not go to jail.

Principal Magistrate Ivy Wasike sentenced Katana on Thursday to a one-year non-custodial sentence and eight months of community service, The Star and Jumuiya reported. He had been convicted of trespassing on private land in Kilifi County on September 4, 2024 and felling 14 trees worth Sh168,792.40 at Red House Beach.

A tree nursery instead of a cell

Under the first count, Katana must keep off the complainant's land and allow a related civil case at the Court of Appeal to run its course. Under the second, he will do community service at the Mnarani chief's office, where he must start a tree nursery with a probation officer.

The magistrate did not hide her view of the irony. "You are an environment protection activist and you are the one making kilns to burn charcoal? Whether or not it is on private land or riparian land, in fact on riparian land is worse," she said, according to The Star.

In mitigation, Katana said he did not cut any trees. He said he found them already felled and was only clearing them from the path to the public beach. Wasike said he had the chance to give that defence earlier, but neither he nor his advocate attended the defence hearing. He has 14 days to appeal.

Riot police and a locked gate

Tension rose early when riot police were deployed and Katana's supporters, relatives and friends were ordered out of the compound. The magistrate later explained that the police were there for a different, dangerous case involving gunshots. After talks with Katana's lawyer, Michael Otieno, his case was heard last and the crowd was let back in.

When the sentence was read, the courtroom erupted. "This proves that the Judiciary is still independent," said Edwin Shamir, coordinator of the Coast Civil Society Network for Human Rights.

'He is our eyes there'

Katana's supporters say the case is about more than trees. Phyllis Omido of the Centre for Justice, Governance and Environmental Action called it a SLAPP suit, a lawsuit used to silence critics. "He is our eyes there and alerts us whenever anything untoward is done. There are attempts to grab that public beach," she said.

Jumuiya notes that Katana has campaigned for years to keep Red House Beach open to the public, and that an earlier court ruling found the beach to be public land. Rights defender Said Famau said public beach access roads must not be turned into private property.

The case comes as Kilifi County warns against people fencing off beach access roads and reclaiming riparian land along the coast, often using title deeds that local groups describe as questionable.

Photos: The Star (Brian Otieno). Thumbnail design: HAMASTA MEDIA.