Five Court of Appeal judges have gone to the High Court in Nairobi to clear their names over claims that they were paid a $2.5 million (Sh325 million) bribe to decide a long-running property dispute between a borrower and Kenya Commercial Bank (KCB), according to Nation Kenya.

Justices Milton Asike-Makhandia, Kathurima M'Inoti, Sankale Ole Kantai, Francis Tuiyott and John Mativo have filed a defamation suit against Captain Kung'u Muigai. Mr Muigai is a nephew of founding President Jomo Kenyatta and a cousin of former President Uhuru Kenyatta.

The case is set for hearing on January 21, 2027.

What the judges want

The suit was filed on August 6, 2026. It says Mr Muigai made the disputed statements at media briefings on September 8 and 10, 2025. The judges say the claims then spread across Facebook, X, LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube, and that other digital outlets republished them.

They deny receiving any bribe or inducement and say the publications harmed their reputations. They are asking the court to declare the statements defamatory and to order an unqualified public apology and the removal of the material. They also want a permanent injunction against further publication, general, exemplary and aggravated damages, interest and costs.

Their advocate, Peter Wanyama, described the bribery allegations as "entirely unfounded and completely preposterous", given the history of the litigation and the nature of the ruling.

Muigai's defence

In a defence filed on September 10, 2026, Mr Muigai denies that his remarks were false, malicious or defamatory and maintains that the 2024 ruling was obtained through a bribe. He pleads justification and privilege, arguing that he was reporting concerns he had raised with the Judicial Service Commission (JSC).

Through his lawyer, Nelson Havi, he argues that a defamation suit is the wrong forum and that the JSC should examine the judges' conduct. He wants the case dismissed as an abuse of court process.

According to his witness statement, he lodged a complaint of gross misconduct against the five judges. The JSC informed him on August 7, 2025, that the complaint had been dismissed, but he says no reasons were given and he later sought a hearing. His lawyer accuses the Judiciary and the JSC of shielding the judges instead of investigating the bribery claim.

A dispute dating back to 1989

The row has its roots in a Sh18.6 million loan that KCB advanced in 1989 to Benjoh Amalgamated Ltd to fund a flower export business under a rural enterprise programme backed by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). Mr Muigai says he was a director and shareholder of Benjoh and of Muiri Coffee Estate Ltd.

The loan was secured against two properties, while Muiri Coffee Estate pledged a third parcel in Kiambu County. After Benjoh defaulted, KCB moved to sell the properties. A day before a May 1992 auction, the companies sued to stop the sale and claimed Sh13 million in losses.

The central question since then has been whether a consent order allowing the bank to sell the properties was recorded before Justice Erastus Githinji on May 4, 1992. Mr Muigai says no such consent exists, relying on a 1997 High Court ruling and a 2018 letter from a deputy registrar.

The Court of Appeal upheld the consent in 2017. Benjoh applied in 2018 to have that decision reviewed, and the five judges dismissed the application on May 24, 2024, stating in their ruling that it was common ground the consent had been recorded in court.

The online bribery allegations surfaced after that ruling, the judges say.

Separate petition pending

The matter has also spawned a constitutional petition filed in 2025 by Mr Muigai, Benjoh and Muiri against several judges and the JSC. It challenges parts of the 2024 ruling and the commission's handling of his complaint, and is yet to be determined.

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Nation Kenya. Read the original report.

Photo: Nation.