Court orders National Bank to pay ex-manager Sh4m after withholding probe report
National Bank of Kenya has been ordered to pay a former senior manager Sh4 million after the Employment and Labour Relations Court found that the lender dismissed him unfairly, partly by refusing to show him the investigation report it used to justify his sacking, according to Business Daily.
Justice Onesmus Makau declared the termination of Kelvin Jumba unfair. The judge held that the bank's decision to keep the report from him undermined the fairness of the disciplinary process. He also faulted the lender for failing to call witnesses to back its claim that Mr Jumba caused a Sh10.9 million loss.
The ruling raises questions about how far employers can go in treating disciplinary investigations as confidential when they rely on them to discipline staff.
From relationship manager to dismissal
Mr Jumba joined the bank in June 2014 as a relationship manager handling county governments. In July 2022 he was promoted to Senior Manager, Special Projects and Partnerships, a role that included seeking business opportunities.
In November 2022, the bank accused him of holding on to invoices from Nouveta Limited worth Sh10.9 million for seven months without sending them for payment. The invoices were for services provided under a three-way arrangement involving the bank, Nouveta and Nairobi City County.
The lender said Mr Jumba received the invoices but neither verified nor approved them, leaving them in his office instead of passing them to the finance department. A second accusation claimed he engaged JamboPay, owned by Webtribe Limited, without internal approvals, without consulting his manager and without completing procurement procedures.
He was suspended on November 2, 2022, and issued with a show-cause letter on November 9. When he replied on November 16, he denied wrongdoing and asked for the investigation report behind the allegations. The bank declined to share the report or any relevant extracts.
Mr Jumba attended a disciplinary hearing on November 29 without a colleague and complained that the panel served as both accuser and decision-maker. He was dismissed in December 2022 for negligence, carelessness, failing to consult his manager and engaging JamboPay without approval. His appeal was rejected in February 2023, prompting him to go to court.
The manager's defence
In court, Mr Jumba admitted that he had not processed the Nouveta invoices. He said the three parties had not finalised their contracts and that Nairobi City County had not released funds. He told the court the bank's financial controller had advised him that payment could not be made until those steps were completed.
He also argued that the revenue-sharing arrangement was new to the bank and that no policy existed on handling invoices from strategic partners under such deals.
On JamboPay, he relied on a June 3, 2021 letter from the bank's managing director to Webtribe, which said the bank was agreeable to a proposed partnership and had assigned a team to develop it.
Bank's case falls short
The bank's Head of Employee Relations, Stephine Opiyo, told the court that departments receiving invoices were required to confirm delivery of services before approving payment, and that the unpaid invoice had sparked a dispute and exposed the bank to loss.
Under cross-examination, however, he conceded that the arrangement was new and could not confirm whether an invoicing guide for June 2021 to March 2022 existed. He also admitted that the bank had not produced its onboarding policy, did not know how JamboPay had been onboarded and had not filed the investigation report in court.
The bank maintained that the report was a confidential management document not meant for employees under investigation.
The court rejected that position, questioning how an employee could defend himself against allegations drawn from evidence he was not allowed to see. Justice Makau said the bank's failure to give Mr Jumba the document "rendered the disciplinary process unfair."
Mr Jumba had sought Sh6.9 million in compensation, equivalent to 12 months' salary, as well as a certificate of service, costs and interest. The court awarded him Sh4 million.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Business Daily. Read the original report. Photo: Business Daily.
More in Crime & Justice
See all.jpeg)
Court gives State 90 days to assess Nairobi residents evicted during 2024 floods
.jpeg)
TSC loses appeal over Sh975,000 award to teacher sacked over harassment claim

High Court Finds CS Mbadi and AG Oduor in Contempt Over Sovereign Bond Secrecy
.jpeg)
Dorita Macharia buried in Murang'a with only one nuclear family member present
.jpeg)
Regina Re accused of telling daughter to change bloodied clothes after grandmother's death







Global Community Remarks
0