The Teachers Service Commission (TSC) has lost an appeal against a magistrate's decision awarding Sh975,000 to a former teacher who was dismissed in 2018 over allegations that he sexually harassed a minor, according to Nation Kenya.

Justice Abuodha Nelson Jorum of the Employment and Labour Relations Court dismissed the commission's appeal and upheld the compensation granted to Dominic Mwanzia Musyoka, who had taught for more than 25 years before losing his job at a secondary school in Makueni County.

In a ruling delivered on November 13, the judge found that the commission had failed to establish the allegations against the teacher and agreed with the lower court that the dismissal was substantively unfair.

Employers must still prove valid reasons

The TSC had argued that the trial magistrate wrongly applied the criminal standard of proof rather than the lower threshold used in employment disputes. It maintained that an employer only needs to show it genuinely believed there were grounds for termination, and that it has a constitutional duty to protect children from abuse.

The commission also contended that Mr Musyoka's acquittal in a criminal case should not have influenced the employment dispute, since disciplinary processes and criminal trials serve different purposes.

Justice Jorum accepted that employers may discipline staff independently of criminal proceedings, even where a court has acquitted them. However, he said this did not relieve the commission of its obligation to show that its reasons for dismissal were valid.

"The Appellant therefore had a duty to justify those serious allegations of sexual harassment against the Respondent," the judge ruled.

He noted that the allegations were grave and demanded proper proof, particularly as the decision ended a long teaching career.

Inconsistencies in the evidence

The dispute dates back to 2017, when the teacher was accused of harassing a pupil. He was interdicted and later dismissed in 2018. Mr Musyoka challenged the decision, arguing that the evidence against him was contradictory and that officials had taken sides in the process.

According to the ruling, the school's Board of Management had raised concerns during the disciplinary proceedings about the differing accounts given by the pupil and her mother. The pupil reportedly placed the alleged incident on January 13, 2017, while her mother gave the date as February 13, 2017.

The board also questioned the testimony of a boy said to have seen the pupil leaving a bathroom in tears. Under questioning, the boy said he had not witnessed the incident but had been told about it by the pupil's brother.

The court further considered a medical report which found no bruises or cuts and indicated the pupil's hymen was intact. The judge noted that the report had been relied upon at the board and county levels, even though the commission later objected to its production in court.

Claims of interference not addressed

Justice Jorum questioned why the commission had not responded to allegations against a TSC sub-county human resource officer, Ms Elizabeth Danson. Mr Musyoka accused her of guiding witnesses as they prepared statements and pressuring the school board to interdict him.

The judge observed that the board had found the reason for interdiction unjustified at an April 3, 2017 meeting, but went ahead to interdict the teacher at a second meeting on April 8 following the officer's intervention. Although she was repeatedly mentioned in the proceedings, she was not called to testify.

The court also noted that claims that the teacher had been asked for money to halt the case were never investigated, and that a headteacher's assertion that Mr Musyoka had confessed was not backed by independent evidence.

Award upheld

The Sh975,000 award comprises Sh75,000 in salary in lieu of notice and Sh900,000, equivalent to 12 months' pay, as compensation for unfair termination.

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Nation Kenya. Read the original report.