High Court lets borrower pursue Stanbic over CRB listing after home auction
A borrower whose Nairobi apartment was auctioned by Stanbic Bank can proceed with a lawsuit challenging the lender's decision to report him negatively to a Credit Reference Bureau (CRB), after the High Court threw out the bank's attempt to have the case struck out.
According to Business Daily, the court dismissed Stanbic's application against Alfred Ogalo Mango, finding that an earlier dispute over the sale of the property did not settle whether the later credit report was lawful or accurate.
The ruling does not decide whether the auction proceeds cleared Mr Mango's debt, or whether the bank had any basis to report him after the sale. Those questions remain open for determination.
Origins of the dispute
The case traces back to a Sh7 million loan that Stanbic extended to Mr Mango in May 2018, followed by a further Sh7.2 million in June 2019, bringing the total to Sh14.2 million. Both facilities were secured by charges over an apartment in Nairobi.
The bank said Mr Mango fell behind on repayments, prompting it to exercise its right to sell the security. The apartment was auctioned and transferred to a new owner in April 2023.
When the buyer demanded vacant possession, Mr Mango sued both Stanbic and the purchaser, contesting the auction and the transfer and seeking to remain in the house.
On September 21, 2024, the High Court turned down his application for an injunction. The Court of Appeal later rejected a further injunction bid. The main suit over the sale is still pending.
The credit listing claim
Earlier this year, Mr Mango filed a separate case targeting the bank's decision to report him to a CRB. He contends that Stanbic listed him negatively after it had already sold the apartment, recovered the loan and closed his account.
He argues that the listing lacked any legal basis and that he was not given notice before it was made.
Stanbic, in its response, said the fresh suit sought to reopen matters that had already been considered, including Mr Mango's default. The lender maintained that sharing the loan information was part of meeting its regulatory obligations.
The bank argued that the case was barred because the same issues had already been decided, describing it as an abuse of the court process, and asked for it to be struck out.
Court draws a line between the cases
The court disagreed. It noted that the earlier rulings dealt only with applications for temporary injunctions and did not amount to a final hearing of the parties' claims.
"The record therefore discloses an undecided suit with a refused interim application," the court ruled.
The judge further distinguished the two disputes, describing the first as concerning "title and possession" while the new case relates to "reputation and credit standing". The causes of action and the remedies sought, the court found, were "different in kind".
With the application dismissed, Mr Mango's credit listing case will now proceed alongside his pending challenge to the auction.
CRB listings in Kenya can affect a borrower's ability to obtain credit from banks and other lenders, making disputes over their accuracy a significant concern for consumers.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Business Daily. Read the original report. Photo: Business Daily.
More in Crime & Justice
See all
Employers Must Do More Than Mark Register Before Sacking Absent Workers, Court Rules
.jpeg)
EACC arrests Kibera DCI officer over alleged Ksh50,000 bribe to record fraud complaint

EACC Arrests Company Director, Staff Over Ksh75,000 Kajiado Title Deed Bribe

Suspect Held in Mowlem Linked to Viral CCTV Gunpoint Robbery at Ruaka Salon

West Pokot Speaker, eight others charged over Ksh260 million Sacco fraud
.jpeg)






Global Community Remarks
0