The High Court has declared that towing charges demanded from motorists by traffic police without clear, publicly known rates or proper paperwork are unconstitutional, according to Nation Kenya.

Justice Lawrence Mugambi found that a Sh8,000 fee demanded from a motorist whose car was towed to Juja Police Station was arbitrary and opaque. He ruled that it offended the national values and principles of governance under Article 10 of the Constitution.

The judge said the demand fell short of the standards of transparency, accountability and respect for property rights. He also found that it went against the rule of law and the principles governing public service, and that it amounted to arbitrary interference with the motorist's property.

"Public authority must not be used to facilitate private commercial advantage to the detriment of the public," Justice Mugambi said.

How the case arose

The petitioner is named as David Kimani in Nation Kenya's summary of the case, while the body of its report refers to him as Mr Waithera. His vehicle was towed to Juja Police Station on December 25, 2025, after police arrested him during a traffic operation.

Police said he appeared to be drunk, refused to take a breathalyser test and disobeyed an officer's instructions. They said nobody else was available to take charge of the car, so they hired a local breakdown operator, Harrison Nzuki, to tow it to the station.

The motorist was released on a cash bail of Sh15,000 and arraigned at the Thika Law Courts on December 29, 2025, over an alleged traffic offence. When he went to collect his car on January 14, 2026, he was asked to pay Sh8,000 in towing charges.

He challenged the demand in court. He argued that police had given him no invoice, no breakdown of costs, no details of who was to be paid and no legal basis for the amount.

Police relied on AA rates

Police told the court that the fee was based on standard Automobile Association (AA) rates. They said the Traffic Act allows them to recover the cost of removing vehicles.

The motorist countered that police had produced neither a contract with the towing operator, nor an invoice showing what was actually spent, nor the AA schedule used. He also asked why rates set by a private motoring association should automatically bind members of the public.

Justice Mugambi agreed that Sections 106 and 107 of the Traffic Act allow police to remove and detain vehicles in certain situations. However, he said those powers do not give officers a free hand to set charges. Motorists, he said, must be able to know in advance how towing fees are worked out and who is entitled to receive the money.

He warned that leaving police and private operators to set fees without clear limits would expose motorists to arbitrary demands and to the seizure of their vehicles.

The judge accepted that limiting police to pre-approved towing firms might be impractical, because traffic incidents can happen anywhere and at any time. Even so, he said charges should follow a standard formula or fixed rates published in advance.

Call for reforms

The court called for urgent changes to the law or to policy guidelines on how towing charges are calculated and collected during traffic enforcement operations.

The judge did not, however, find that towing the motorist's car was itself unlawful. He said the traffic court hearing the pending case was better placed to decide whether removing the vehicle was justified and whether the motorist should pay.

The Sh8,000 demand has been suspended until the traffic case is concluded. That court will decide whether any amount is payable and, if so, set the proper figure based on evidence and justification from the police.

The vehicle was released after the motorist deposited the disputed Sh8,000 in court on January 30, 2026. The money will stay in court until the traffic court rules.

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Nation Kenya. Read the original report.