High Court Lifts Order Blocking CJ Koome and JSC From Publishing Judges' Performance Data
The High Court has lifted an order that stopped Chief Justice Martha Koome and the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) from publishing the individual performance records of judges and judicial officers, just one day after the restriction was imposed.
Justice David Mburu, in a ruling delivered on Friday, discharged the conservatory order he had issued on Thursday, November 19. The order had barred the publication of the data in the State of the Judiciary and Administration of Justice Report (SOJAR), which was scheduled for launch on Friday, November 20, according to Kenyans.co.ke.
Order 'overtaken by events'
According to court documents seen by Kenyans.co.ke, the judge set aside the ex-parte order, which had prohibited the Chief Justice and the JSC from releasing individual performance figures in any form, including as an addendum or appendix to the report.
Justice Mburu said circumstances had changed since he issued the initial directive, and that the order no longer served a practical purpose.
"Courts do not issue orders in vain," the judge said.
He found that the conservatory order had been overtaken by events, leading him to discharge it.
Concerns raised in the petition
The original order arose from a petition opposing the planned disclosure of performance data for individual judicial officers. The petitioner argued that there was no clear regulatory framework governing how such information should be published.
He warned that releasing the figures without proper context could expose judges and magistrates to public ridicule and online harassment, as well as reveal sensitive personal information.
The petition also questioned whether the data had been adequately verified. It argued that incomplete figures, or figures presented selectively, could give the public a misleading picture of how individual judges perform.
The petitioner, however, maintained that he was not against accountability in the Judiciary. His case, according to Kenyans.co.ke, is that clear guidelines should first be put in place to ensure the information is presented fairly and accurately.
Case still alive
While Friday's ruling removes the legal obstacle to publication, it is not a final decision on the petition itself. The questions raised about how judicial performance data should be handled remain before the court.
The court has certified the application as urgent and admitted it for an initial hearing without first requiring the other parties to respond.
The matter is set to return to court on December 1, 2026. On that date, the parties are expected to confirm that they have filed their written submissions and to receive further directions from the court.
What the ruling means
The decision means the Chief Justice and the JSC are no longer legally restrained from including individual performance records in the SOJAR, the Judiciary's report on its work and the state of justice delivery in the country.
The publication of performance data for individual judicial officers has drawn attention because it would put the output of specific judges and magistrates in the public domain, rather than only aggregated figures for the courts.
How the court ultimately rules on the petition could shape whether, and under what rules, such data is released in future.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Kenyans.co.ke. Read the original report. Photo: Kenyans.co.ke.
More in Crime & Justice
See all
Supreme Court finally gets title deeds for its land, a year after Kindiki's directive

Court clears extradition of Brian Kiplagat to UK over death of Kenyan woman

JSC handles 259 petitions against judges as 127 new complaints filed in a year

NPS Sets December 10 Date for Nationwide Police Constable Recruitment

Family of missing Baringo herdsman goes to court, says abductors want KSh 1m ransom







Global Community Remarks
0