The High Court in Nairobi has upheld a will in which a mother left her family land to a single daughter, ruling that her other children could not claim a share of the property simply because they had been left out.

The decision, delivered on Thursday, November 19, according to Kenyans.co.ke, reaffirms that a parent may pass property to one child and exclude others, provided the will was properly made.

How the dispute arose

The case was filed by three children and a granddaughter of the deceased woman. They challenged a will that placed the family land under the care of one of her daughters, who had also been named executor of the estate and was therefore charged with administering it.

Court documents showed the objectors raised several grounds. They claimed their mother had not properly signed or thumbprinted the document. They also argued that she was elderly and unwell at the time and may have lacked the mental capacity to make a will.

In addition, they said the will was unfair because it shut out the other children, and suggested their sister may have influenced their mother into leaving the land to her.

Court finds no proof of incapacity or influence

The judge rejected these arguments. The court found that the objectors had not presented medical records or any other persuasive evidence showing that the woman was mentally incapable of making a will on January 19, 2000, the date the document was drawn up. She was therefore presumed to have been of sound mind.

On the claim of undue influence, the court noted that the daughter was not present when her mother gave instructions for the will or when it was executed. This, the judge found, left insufficient evidence that the daughter had pressured or manipulated her mother.

The judge concluded that the will had been executed in line with Section 11 of the Law of Succession Act, that it was authentic, and that it reflected the deceased's genuine wishes. The objectors, the court said, had failed to prove fraud, coercion or undue influence.

Freedom to choose beneficiaries

In the ruling, the judge explained that succession law permits people to leave their property to beneficiaries of their choosing.

The court acknowledged that Section 26 of the Act allows dependants who have not been reasonably provided for to ask the court to make provision for them. However, the three children did not supply adequate evidence of their financial needs, their available resources, any earlier benefits received from their mother, or the value of the estate.

The judge also pointed to clause 3 of the will, in which the mother explained her decision. She stated she had made the disposition "because all her sons and daughters had inherited her late husband's properties", the judge noted.

Given the limited evidence, the court said it could not determine whether the children deserved any additional provision from their mother's estate.

What the ruling means

The judgment offers guidance on a common source of family disputes, in which a parent bequeaths land to one child while leaving others out. According to Kenyans.co.ke, the ruling confirms that such a will can stand if it is validly made.

Children who are excluded, however, still retain the option of applying for reasonable provision under the Law of Succession Act, provided they can back their claims with sufficient evidence.

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Kenyans.co.ke. Read the original report. Photo: Kenyans.co.ke.