UN talks on 'killer robots' stall as major powers block binding treaty
A United Nations conference in Geneva has ended without agreement to begin negotiating legally binding rules on autonomous weapon systems, often called "killer robots". Opposition from several major arms-producing nations led to a weaker compromise that critics say offers no clear path to a treaty, according to Al Jazeera.
Member states of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) met in the Swiss city for a week. On Saturday they agreed only to "elaborate" on a possible instrument regulating such weapons by 2028, rather than securing a mandate to negotiate a binding ban.
Who blocked the push
The United States, Russia and Israel opposed moves towards binding rules, Al Jazeera reported. Because decisions under the convention require consensus among all members, any single country can block progress.
Two European Union diplomats told Politico that the United Kingdom, South Korea, Japan, Turkiye and Israel were also among the states that resisted. According to diplomats quoted by The Guardian, supporters of a new convention included the EU, NATO member states, Ukraine, China and Iran.
Diplomats told Reuters that talks on the final wording ran through the night, after Russian objections to procedural rules forced the cancellation of some formal sessions. One diplomat from a country backing new laws described the outcome to Reuters as disappointing, but said it could have been much worse.
Julien Thoeni, the Swiss diplomat who chaired the conference, told reporters that some countries had rejected the word "negotiate". The agreed text therefore refers to the "elaboration" of an instrument instead.
Major powers prefer flexibility
Although most countries back a pact, major military powers argue that existing international humanitarian law already covers these weapons. As spending on AI-driven warfare grows, they have resisted restrictions that could limit their ability to develop, test or deploy advanced systems. They prefer non-binding frameworks or longer timelines for discussion.
The talks came a month after nearly 100 countries agreed that legally binding rules should be adopted quickly for weapons that can kill without a human making the final decision to fire.
What the weapons are
The UN describes lethal autonomous weapon systems as combinations of weapons and technology that can identify, select and engage targets, resulting in loss of life, without a human operator stepping in. The term "killer robots" is widely used but has no established technical or legal meaning.
Such systems are loaded with a "target profile" before deployment. They then use sensor data, including facial recognition, to find and attack matching targets.
The UN notes that not every autonomous weapon relies on artificial intelligence. However, it warns that using AI to pick and strike targets can deepen legal, ethical, humanitarian and security concerns.
AI-assisted weapons have already been used in the wars in Ukraine and Sudan and in Middle East conflicts, including Israel's use of AI-powered targeting systems in Gaza, Al Jazeera reported.
The CCW, adopted in 1980, aims to ban or restrict weapons considered to cause unnecessary suffering or to harm civilians indiscriminately. It has 128 states parties, but no binding instrument under it currently addresses autonomous weapons specifically.
Rights groups react
Stop Killer Robots, a coalition of about 300 organisations, said the mandate had been watered down and offered no clear route to binding rules. Its executive director, Nicole van Rooijen, noted that autonomous weapons, including some using AI to choose targets, were already being used in combat.
"Delaying the creation of a legally binding instrument puts civilians and humanity at risk," van Rooijen told AFP.
Georgia Hinds, a legal adviser at the International Committee of the Red Cross, said leaving life-and-death decisions to algorithms raised a fundamental ethical problem. She argued that better technology could not fix it and described it as a moral red line.
Critics also warn that, without a binding treaty, such weapons reduce human beings to sensor data and algorithmic targets, undermining their dignity.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Al Jazeera. Read the original report. Photo: Al Jazeera.
More in International
See all
Saudi Arabia downs Houthi drone and missile as Sanaa fuel station strike wounds six

Gaza children with diabetes face life-threatening insulin and test strip shortages

New Zealand Opens Post-Study Work Visa to Graduate Diploma Holders With Foreign Degrees

Palestinian refugees born in Egypt still treated as foreigners decades after Nakba

Israeli settlers torch cars, deface homes in West Bank villages near Ramallah
.jpeg)






Global Community Remarks
0