A court in Cairo on Wednesday suspended the trial of Lina Attalah, chief editor of Egypt's leading independent news outlet Mada Masr, after her defence team asked for the presiding judge to step aside, according to Africanews.

Attalah faces up to a year in jail on charges of publishing false news and running a website without a licence. The suspension came a week after the court had already postponed the hearing.

In a statement posted on X, Mada Masr said the proceedings were on hold until a separate court rules on the recusal request, a hearing scheduled for 26 November.

Defence questions judge's impartiality

Attalah's lawyers argued that Judge Mohamed Mubarak had already made up his mind about her guilt. They pointed to a separate case last month in which the same judge ruled against her in what has been described as a rushed trial.

Speaking to AFP last week, Attalah said the judge had insisted the matter was simple and needed little time.

According to the report, during that earlier hearing Mubarak appointed his own lawyer to represent Attalah, even though her eight-member defence team was present in court, and then went on to draft the defence statement himself. He subsequently fined her three million Egyptian pounds, roughly $56,000, and ordered that Mada Masr be shut down.

A retrial after an unknown sentence

Wednesday's proceedings were a retrial. During the October hearing, Attalah discovered that she had been handed a one-year prison sentence in absentia in 2024, without having been informed.

Mada Masr says it has applied for a licence several times, but its applications have largely gone unanswered. The outlet has continued operating through more than a decade of restrictions on the press in Egypt.

International criticism

The case has drawn criticism from the United Nations and human rights organisations. The UN has condemned what it described as widening attacks on press freedom in Egypt, saying Attalah's prosecution raised concerns about due process and guarantees of a fair trial.

Egypt has long faced criticism over its human rights record. According to Africanews, the country is currently holding 26 journalists in detention.

Among them are six members of the fact-checking platform Matsadaash, who were arrested at the same time in September, a move that triggered an international outcry.

What happens next

The fate of the trial now depends on the 26 November ruling. Should the separate court agree that Judge Mubarak must withdraw, the case would be expected to proceed before a different judge. If the request is rejected, proceedings against Attalah could resume before the same bench.

For press freedom advocates, the outcome is being closely watched as a test of how Egypt's courts treat independent journalism, with Mada Masr's survival as an outlet also hanging on the earlier order for its closure.

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Africanews. Read the original report. Photo: Africanews.