High Court rejects bid to reopen sale of Sh271m ship Dolphin Star
The High Court has thrown out an application by the owners of the cargo ship Dolphin Star seeking to undo an agreement that handed the vessel and its timber cargo to ET Timbers Pte Limited, Nation Kenya reports.
Justice Jairus Ngaah, in a ruling delivered on November 20, dismissed the owners' request to reverse orders issued in April 2025. Those orders allowed ET Timbers to take the ship for $2.1 million (about Sh271 million) and its cargo of round logs for $135,000 (about Sh17 million).
The owners had wanted the transfer declared invalid and the ship put up for sale afresh through an open tender. They were also ordered to pay the costs of the case.
Dispute over a missed deadline
At the centre of the application was a 21-day deadline, which lapsed on May 19, 2025, within which ET Timbers was to clear Kenya Ports Authority (KPA) charges and cover the expenses of the Admiralty Marshal. The owners argued that the company's failure to pay on time should void the deal.
Justice Ngaah disagreed. He held that the parties had freely consented to the arrangement, which was recorded in court with their lawyers present, and that a delay in carrying out one of its terms did not automatically cancel it.
"That is a complaint about performance, not about the validity of the consent," the judge said, according to Nation Kenya.
He noted that the agreement did not provide that missing the deadline would cancel the sale or require a new tender. He also observed that KPA, the party entitled to the charges, had neither backed the application nor complained about the delay.
Ship already transferred and renamed
The court heard that ET Timbers had since paid the required charges and expenses, and the vessel had been passed to a new owner and given a new name. The judge said reversing the sale would affect the rights of that new owner, who was not part of the application.
He added that courts are reluctant to undo a completed judicial sale, particularly when the request comes from the debtor whose property was sold and rests only on a late payment owed to third parties.
Claims lacked evidence
The owners had also argued that the ship had been anchored for too long and risked sinking with its cargo, potentially harming the marine environment, and that ET Timbers lacked the financial means to complete the purchase.
Justice Ngaah gave these claims no weight. The only affidavit filed was sworn by Patrick Njuguna, an advocate for the owners, and no survey report, statement from the crew or owners, or communication from the port authority or Admiralty Marshal was produced.
The judge further questioned the logic of seeking a third tender more than a year later when two earlier attempts had failed and the owners themselves were claiming the vessel had deteriorated.
Background to the case
The dispute began with a claim filed by ET Timbers against the ship's owners, with KPA as an interested party. On May 24, 2024, the High Court ruled in favour of ET Timbers and ordered the valuation and sale of the vessel and its timber.
The owners' appeals, both on the court's jurisdiction and the judgment, were dismissed by the Court of Appeal in April 2025.
Two public tenders failed. The first, advertised on September 5, 2024, drew no bids. A second, advertised on March 13, 2025, attracted two bids, but both were rejected when opened on April 11, 2025 because the bidders had not paid the mandatory 25 per cent deposit.
ET Timbers then offered on April 14, 2025 to take the ship and cargo in partial settlement of its debt. Because the sum owed, including interest, exceeded the purchase price, the company was not required to pay separately for them. Lawyers for all three parties agreed to the deal on April 28, 2025.
The ruling also touched on a May 29, 2025 email from Defang Shipping Company Limited, described as the owners, alleging corrupt practices. The judge said those claims were not part of the application and were not backed by sworn evidence.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Nation Kenya. Read the original report.
More in Crime & Justice
See all
Ship agents urge faster upgrades at Mombasa and Lamu ports to curb congestion

Six oil tankers among 51 ships expected at Mombasa and Lamu ports by end of October
.jpeg)
Court rejects civil society bid to inspect State House over church construction

Saudi-led coalition and Houthis trade threats to bomb Red Sea ports as strikes escalate

Court rejects urgent bid to freeze Dangote's KPC stake ahead of AGM







Global Community Remarks
0