Court rejects civil society bid to inspect State House over church construction
The High Court has dismissed an application by civil society groups seeking to inspect State House grounds in Nairobi, where they claim construction of a church is nearly finished despite a court order stopping the project.
Justice David Mburu ruled that the petitioners had presented no evidence to justify a site visit, and that courts should not search for evidence on behalf of litigants, Nation Kenya reports.
Claims from a confidential source
The application was brought by Transparency International Kenya, the Kenya Human Rights Commission, Inuka Kenya Ni Sisi and the Institute of Social Accountability. They told the court a confidential source had informed them that the church, reported by Nation Kenya to cost Sh1.8 billion, was almost complete.
If true, the groups argued, the work would have gone ahead in disregard of a court order dated August 26, 2025.
Their lawyer asked for an inspection to establish whether the building had been put up and whether the petition had been overtaken by events. He told the court the groups would withdraw the case if the church had already been completed, and argued that State House was a protected area they could not access to gather evidence. He declined to name his source, citing legal protections for whistleblowers.
AG dismisses claims as rumours
The Attorney-General opposed the request, describing the claims as rumours that were not backed by an affidavit or any documents. The AG said the groups should have filed a formal application supported by evidence.
Katiba Institute backed the inspection, with its lawyer arguing that the Government should permit a visit if it had nothing to hide.
Court's reasoning
Justice Mburu held that while the Civil Procedure Rules allow inspections to clarify disputed matters, such visits are meant to help a court understand evidence already presented, not to replace a party's duty to prove its case.
"The petitioners are trying to use the court as a vessel for the collection of evidence," the judge said.
He found that an inspection was unnecessary before the main petition is heard.
Background to the dispute
The groups went to court in August 2025 to challenge the planned construction of a permanent church at State House. They argue the project breaches constitutional provisions on the separation of State and religion, public land and resources, equality, freedom of belief and public participation.
Their petition leans on Article 8 of the Constitution, which states there shall be no State religion, and seeks constitutional declarations. A third petition challenging the project has also been filed, according to Nation Kenya.
The organisations further contend that private funding would not settle questions about the use of State land, facilities and staff.
President William Ruto said in July 2025 that he had found an iron-sheet prayer structure at State House and wanted a permanent building in its place. He said the church would be paid for through private donations and disputed reports that it would cost Sh1.2 billion, putting the figure at Sh350 million.
The petitioners have cited a State House letter dated July 11, 2025, which they say confirmed that the project was funded by private donations led by the President, with no public money involved.
The court has yet to determine whether the proposed church violates the Constitution.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Nation Kenya. Read the original report.
More in Crime & Justice
See all.jpeg)
High Court rejects bid to reopen sale of Sh271m ship Dolphin Star

Murkomen hits back at Bishop Muheria over ban on politicians at church fundraisers

Flagship Biography: William Samoei Arap Ruto
.jpeg)
Church-run circumcision camps draw fees of up to Sh50,000 as elders cry foul

WHEN SOCIETY NAMES YOU, YOU BECOME IT







Global Community Remarks
0