The pictures on your phone that you never posted, the family snaps, screenshots and videos sitting quietly in your gallery, are at the centre of one of the biggest privacy penalties Italy has ever handed a technology company. The country's data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million (about $887 million) after finding that the Facebook app on Android phones accessed users' photos without their specific consent.

The regulator, known as the Garante, announced the decision on Saturday. It said the app "accessed photos, videos and associated metadata stored on Italian users' smartphones without specific consent and without informing them". Around 20 million Android users in Italy may have been affected.

The feature at the heart of the case

The ruling concerns a Facebook function labelled "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook". It draws on a phone's gallery to propose photos and videos the user might want to post.

According to the Garante, the problem lies in how permission was obtained. Facebook asked for access to the photo gallery through a single, app-wide authorisation, and the notice shown beforehand did not make clear that agreeing would also let the app generate suggestions from private pictures. The suggestions option was also switched on by default.

The authority said this breached the Italian law that implements the European Union's ePrivacy directive.

Why the fine is so large

  • €805 million is by far the biggest penalty the Italian regulator has ever imposed
  • It is equal to roughly 0.47 per cent of Meta's global turnover
  • The watchdog cited "the high number of people affected" and the fact the practice is ongoing for users who have not updated the app or who already gave consent
  • It also pointed to a "lack of cooperation" by Meta and an earlier violation that led to a fine in 2019

Meta has been given 60 days to disable the feature by default and to seek users' consent for it separately. The proceedings did not examine whether gallery content might be used to train artificial intelligence, something Meta denies doing.

When the decision was reported on Saturday, the company had not commented publicly. It has the right to appeal.

A bruising run for the Facebook owner

The Italian decision lands only weeks after a judge in the US state of New Mexico ordered Meta to pay $25 billion following a trial that found the company had spent years misleading the public about how it handled Facebook user data, the BBC reported. Meta also owns Instagram and WhatsApp.

What it means for Facebook users in Kenya

The ruling applies only to Italy, and the regulator made no finding about other countries. But Facebook is one of the most widely used apps on Android phones, and Android is the dominant phone system in Kenya, so the questions the Italian watchdog raised about consent will sound familiar here.

Users who want to check for themselves can look through the Facebook app's settings for gallery or camera roll suggestions, and can review which apps are allowed to see their photos in their phone's permission settings. Kenya's own Data Protection Act requires that consent for processing personal data be informed and specific, the same principle the Italian regulator says was missing in this case.

Photos: Ezra Acayan/Getty Images via Al Jazeera; Meta headquarters, Menlo Park by InvadingInvader (CC BY-SA 4.0), via Wikimedia Commons. Thumbnail design: HAMASTA MEDIA.