Mbadi Rules Out Cancelling CRBC Contracts After World Bank Flags SGR Costs
The government will not cancel contracts awarded to China Roads and Bridges Corporation (CRBC), Treasury Cabinet Secretary John Mbadi has said, despite renewed pressure following a World Bank report that questioned the cost of Kenya's Standard Gauge Railway (SGR).
Speaking in an interview on Citizen TV on Tuesday, Mbadi argued that the report did not place the Chinese contractor at the centre of any wrongdoing. He said terminating deals already awarded to the firm on the strength of that document would be unfair, according to Kenyans.co.ke.
Cost concerns over the SGR
The World Bank's latest Kenya Economic Update, released earlier this month, raised questions over several projects, most notably the cost of building Phase One of the SGR between Mombasa and Naivasha.
According to the report, the Mombasa–Nairobi stretch cost about Ksh988 million per kilometre. The Bank compared this with roughly Ksh741 million per kilometre for Tanzania's electrified Dar es Salaam–Dodoma line and about Ksh689 million for the electrified railway linking Djibouti and Addis Ababa.
Had Kenya built its line at Tanzania's rate, the lender estimated, the country could have saved as much as Ksh116 billion across the whole project.
The findings have fuelled calls for the State to revoke other deals held by CRBC, which has secured a string of major infrastructure contracts in Kenya in recent years. These include the Ksh154 billion expansion of Jomo Kenyatta International Airport (JKIA) and the construction of the Rironi–Mau Summit highway, among other multi-billion-shilling projects.
Mbadi: treat each project separately
Mbadi said he preferred to separate the projects and examine each on its own merits. While acknowledging that Kenya might have spent less on the Mombasa–Naivasha railway, he said the reasons behind the higher costs needed closer scrutiny.
He suggested that cost escalation on such projects is often driven by land compensation rather than by the contractor itself.
The CS urged members of the public to read and understand the World Bank report and to establish what actually pushed up the cost of the railway before drawing conclusions about the firm.
Risk of court battles
Mbadi maintained that CRBC followed due process in winning its contracts and pointed out that the company has not been blacklisted. He warned that cancelling the tenders could drag the government into protracted litigation that it might ultimately lose.
"If we cancel the tenders, they can take us to court and win," Mbadi said.
He added that he saw no reason why the firm should not be awarded further work in future if it applied and won through a competitive process.
On the Rironi–Mau Summit road, the CS said he had not come across anything questionable, although he noted that the Auditor General could still raise issues. He expressed confidence that the procurement process for the project had been properly followed.
What next
Mbadi's remarks signal that the Treasury intends to stand by existing agreements with CRBC, even as debate continues over value for money in large, externally financed infrastructure projects. The SGR, Kenya's flagship railway project, has long attracted scrutiny over its cost and financing.
Whether the World Bank's findings will prompt further investigations into the cost escalation, including the role of land compensation, remains to be seen.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Kenyans.co.ke. Read the original report. Photo: Kenyans.co.ke.
More in Business
See all
KRA explains how factories can issue eTIMS invoices on behalf of small-scale farmers

Oparanya urges Kisii, Nyamira cooperatives to tap climate finance to cut costs

Jambojet cuts fuel costs by 16% using flight data and single-engine taxiing

Stanbic Bank Kenya nine-month profit rises 10pc to Sh10.32bn

US-Linked Consortium Picked for Ksh8 Trillion Mrima Hill Project as Joho Sets Conditions
.jpeg)






Global Community Remarks
0