The United States has asked Ukraine whether it would be prepared to give up the parts of Donetsk province it still holds in return for NATO membership or comparable security guarantees, according to DW News. Ukrainian analysts have warned that such a deal would be risky and could leave Kyiv with promises that cannot be enforced.

Donetsk and neighbouring Luhansk together form the Donbas region in eastern Ukraine. Russia controls most of Luhansk and large parts of Donetsk, but Ukrainian forces still hold several major cities in Donetsk, among them Kramatorsk and Sloviansk.

Zelenskyy: no concrete proposal yet

President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said no concrete proposal had been tabled so far. He indicated he would discuss the matter publicly only once the US and NATO member states had agreed on a plan, adding that he could not take such a decision by himself.

Zelenskyy also said any possible agreement would proceed without recognition of Russia's occupation of the territories.

According to the Ukrainian leader, Washington has spoken of guarantees resembling Articles 4 and 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, though without American troops stationed in Ukraine. Article 4 provides for consultations among members facing an imminent threat, while Article 5 treats an attack on one member as an attack on all.

The US, however, has said it envisages bilateral guarantees for Ukraine along the lines of those it has with Israel and some Middle Eastern states.

Moscow has not commented on the proposals. Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said it was not appropriate to disclose details of talks between Russia and the Americans in the interest of the peace process.

Fears of a 'second Budapest Memorandum'

Experts who spoke to DW News doubted that the US could uphold such an arrangement on its own. Oleksandr Kraiev of the Ukrainian Prism think tank said at least half of NATO's members had reservations about admitting Ukraine.

"We'll just end up with a second Budapest Memorandum, it'll just carry a different name," Kraiev told DW News.

Under the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, Russia, the US and the UK pledged to respect Ukraine's sovereignty and borders and to refrain from using force against it, while Ukraine gave up its nuclear weapons. The agreement contained no commitment by Washington or London to defend Ukraine if it were attacked.

Referendum idea criticised

Most analysts interviewed by DW News also opposed putting the question to a referendum. Oleksandr Khara of the Centre for Defence Strategies argued that ceding territory would breach Ukraine's constitution, damage its national interests and weaken the principle that borders cannot be changed by force. He said the outcome of any vote would be irrelevant and that such a referendum would set a dangerous precedent.

Public opinion appears firmly against the idea. A Kyiv International Institute of Sociology survey carried out between 8 and 16 October found that 61 per cent of respondents rejected withdrawing troops from Ukrainian-held parts of Donbas, even in return for US and European guarantees. Some 35 per cent said they would reluctantly accept such a deal.

Khara also questioned whether an Israel-style bilateral pact with the US would give Kyiv more than it already receives, such as financial aid, joint weapons production and troop training. He said that, ideally, Ukraine would need a nuclear shield, strategic from the US and tactical from Europe, to deter another war.

The West German model

Sergiy Solodkyy of the New Europe research centre said Ukrainian experts proposed an alternative in December 2023: Ukraine would join NATO within its internationally recognised borders, but protocols would limit collective defence to territory under Kyiv's control.

He compared this to West Germany, which joined NATO before reunification, with the east entering only later. Solodkyy said West Germany never abandoned reunification and Ukraine should likewise not give up territory or recognise a new border. He described the land-for-security proposal as "a trap" that Russian and US negotiators were trying to draw Kyiv into.

This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by DW News. Read the original report. Photo: DW News.