KRA wins 52pc of tax disputes as firms falter on records and deadlines
Kenyan businesses are losing most of their tax disputes with the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA), largely because they cannot produce records, prove their claims or meet legal deadlines, according to a new study reported by Business Daily.
The analysis by Nairobi-based tax, legal and accounting firm Tarra Agility Africa found that KRA won 52 percent of 5,250 tax disputes decided between 2011 and 2026. Taxpayers prevailed in 36 percent of cases, while the remaining 12 percent ended in split or partial rulings.
Nearly half of the taxman's wins were tied to missing or inadequate documentation, leaving companies exposed to additional assessments, penalties and interest that could run into billions of shillings.
Rising win rate for the taxman
The report, titled The Silent Liability, shows KRA's annual success rate has risen from about a third in 2020 to nearly six in 10 in 2026. It reviewed decisions of the Tax Appeals Tribunal and the courts using the firm's Africa Tax Terminal, a platform that tracks tax legislation, rulings and KRA notices.
According to the study, about 35 percent of KRA's victories stemmed from taxpayers' failure to discharge the burden of proof, while 23 percent involved objections or appeals filed outside statutory timelines. The categories overlap, as they were derived from keyword analysis of the decisions.
The report argues that these losses rarely turn on how the law is interpreted, but on process failures that sit squarely with company finance departments.
Beatrice Njeri, a partner in tax compliance and accounting at the firm, said many companies treat tax health checks as a once-a-year exercise and fail to act on the findings. "Most Kenyan businesses check their tax position once a year. The law doesn't wait that long," she said.
Burden of proof on taxpayers
Under Section 56(1) of the Tax Procedures Act, the taxpayer, not the Commissioner, must prove that an assessment is excessive or wrong. Businesses are also required to keep records for five years and produce them on request.
Taxpayers have 30 days to formally object to an assessment, while the Commissioner has 60 days to respond. Missing these deadlines can bar a company from contesting an assessment on its merits.
Costs can also mount over time, since interest and penalties accrue from the date tax fell due rather than when a firm discovers the problem.
Among cases cited, Paleah Stores lost a Sh9.25 billion VAT and corporation tax dispute after failing to produce records, while Hashi Energy lost a Sh7.18 billion case after the court ruled its business was managed and controlled from Kenya. In contrast, Wildlife Works overturned a Sh6.89 billion transfer-pricing adjustment by showing its related-party deals were at arm's length and properly documented.
Record collections amid fiscal pressure
The findings come as KRA steps up revenue mobilisation. The authority collected a record Sh2.844 trillion in the year to June 2026, up 10.6 percent from Sh2.572 trillion. Exchequer collections reached Sh2.568 trillion against a Sh2.698 trillion target, a 95.2 percent performance.
Debt recovery brought in Sh144.82 billion, nearly 16 times the Sh9.1 billion raised from recruiting new taxpayers. Alternative dispute resolution yielded Sh35.06 billion from 993 cases, more than double the previous year's Sh15.3 billion from 97 cases.
The Treasury put the fiscal deficit, including grants, at Sh1.265 trillion, or 6.8 percent of GDP, in FY2025-26.
Laws amended after court defeats
Where businesses have won, the government has often responded through legislation. The Finance Bill 2026 included proposals linked to cases involving Absa Bank Kenya, Pesapal, Githima Limited and Katahira & Engineers International, among them 16 percent VAT on payment platforms and allowing KRA to issue agency notices on assessments under appeal.
The World Bank's 2025 Enterprise Survey found 64 percent of firms viewed tax rates as a major or very severe constraint, with 38.6 percent citing tax administration.
Demand for tax expertise is also rising, with KPMG East Africa recently hiring at least four senior tax executives from Deloitte.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by Business Daily. Read the original report. Photo: Business Daily.
More in Business
See all
KRA rejects KenGen's Sh6bn tax break claims on power plant investments

KRA warns businesses, landlords and digital firms of November 20 tax deadline

KRA's rental tax net closes in on over one million landlords as eRITS matches property records with declarations

KRA moves to seize Sh623m from Mike Sonko's bank in alleged income tax arrears

Koome swears in 18 PPDT members, urges early preparation for 2027 party disputes







Global Community Remarks
0