Seated in tents next to the grave of Joseph Murumbi, Kenya's second Vice-President, about 80 Nairobi residents spent three hours on Friday telling county officials they do not want a crematorium built in City Park.

The meeting on November 13 was the county's second public consultation on the proposal, The Star reported. Speaker after speaker described the idea as "out of the question", and when county officials invited them to walk over and view the proposed site, the residents shook their heads and said no, even after being told the visit would not be taken as an endorsement.

"Is this proposal even worth discussing?" asked Teddy Obero, secretary of the Parklands Residents Association.

Where the idea came from

The plan began with a petition to the Nairobi City County Assembly. On August 13, MCAs passed a Motion sponsored by Karura Ward MCA Thuo Fiu ni Fiu asking the county executive to study the feasibility of a public "green" crematorium next to the Murumbi Peace Memorial Park, at the City Park Goan Cemetery, according to the Nation.

The MCA argues that Nairobi's growing population needs more options for laying loved ones to rest. Sub-county administrator James Ochende told the meeting that Lang'ata Cemetery was "full to the brim". Fiu ni Fiu told the Nation that nothing would be built tomorrow, and that the county executive is expected to table its feasibility report in the second week of December.

At a separate forum reported by Capital FM, some residents backed a modern electric crematorium as a cheaper and dignified alternative to costly burials, while others questioned the location.

Why residents say no

Opponents at Friday's meeting, including the Muthaiga Residents Association, the Westlands Informal Residents Association, the Kenya Peasants League and the Green Belt Movement, said the park should not lose any more land.

  • Lawyer Alliya Mersi said Kariokor crematorium is only 2.5km away and the Lang'ata facility 10km away, and both have room to expand.
  • Obero said the Sh45 million set aside by the defunct Nairobi Metropolitan Services in 2021/22 for a crematorium should instead fence and restore the park, "the lungs of Nairobi that are left".
  • Urban planner Geri Sherere warned of possible public health risks.
  • Friends of City Park chair Dion Koigi told the Nation the group is not against cremation, but the site lies inside the protected area and close to the graves of Murumbi, his wife Sheila and Pio Gama Pinto.

A park that keeps shrinking

City Park was set aside as an urban park in 1923, and part of it was declared a national monument in 2009. Conservationists say it has lost large parts of its original land over the decades. Residents also complained that letters asking who was behind the proposal had gone unanswered.

Alice Macaire, who co-founded the Friends of Karura Forest with Wangari Maathai, called the meeting "democracy at work". The views gathered will go into a report for the County Assembly, which will decide the next step.

Photos: Carlillasa via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0); The Star (screengrab). Thumbnail design: HAMASTA MEDIA.