NATO grapples with sovereignty risks as militaries lean on private tech and AI
NATO military chiefs and defence experts have been wrestling with how armed forces can embrace artificial intelligence and advanced technology without handing control of sensitive data and capabilities to private companies, according to France 24.
The debate dominated NATO Edge, a three-day conference on critical technologies and digital warfare held this week in Izmir, Turkey. It brought together military leaders, government officials and specialists from the alliance's 32 member states, as well as Ukraine.
A clash of priorities
At the heart of the problem is a mismatch between two very different worlds. Technology firms are shaped by market pressures and answer to private investors seeking returns, not to elected governments. Armed forces, by contrast, operate under political authority and place great weight on strategy, chain of command and secrecy.
Linking the two is the push to build a connected battlefield, where everything from troop coordination to live terrain analysis depends on enormous volumes of data. That information, France 24 noted, can shape the outcome of a war and determine whether lives are saved or lost.
The Starlink example
One case in particular illustrates the risk: SpaceX's civilian Starlink satellite network and its military counterpart, Starshield. Ukraine has depended heavily on these services since Russia's full-scale invasion in 2022, yet Kyiv has faced limits on access to Starshield, which is owned by Elon Musk's company.
Musk has changed his position on Ukraine several times, and has argued that any interruption to service was a matter for the United States government rather than SpaceX. That uncertainty hung over discussions in Izmir.
A representative of a US company, speaking anonymously, told France 24 there was strong pressure for governments and militaries to work more closely with industry, but warned of a fine line. He pointed to reports of Musk slowing internet access in Ukraine as a cautionary tale, and argued that militaries did not need total sovereignty, only enough of it.
Trust as the deciding factor
Tom Barton, an analyst at intelligence firm Janes, said many defence ministries were struggling with the issue. He explained that companies building networked battlefield systems ideally need some access to confidential data, and that militaries are experimenting with different levels of trust and access across space, land sensors and communications.
Major General Rainer Beeck, one of NATO's senior cyberspace commanders, described the matter as a hard nut to crack, saying decisions on how to classify different types of data ultimately come down to trust. Admiral Pierre Vandier, NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation, likewise said trust was paramount, whether in system architecture, data sharing, AI agents or decision-making tools.
Ukraine, after nearly five years of war, has more practical experience of these questions than any NATO member, France 24 reported.
Big and small budgets
The challenge also looks different depending on a country's defence spending. Beeck said large powers would have no difficulty gathering data if war broke out, but warned that by then it would be too late to organise it, urging a more forward-looking approach.
Mitch Free, vice president of international government at satellite imagery provider Vantor, said smaller governments need to build up their capacity. Many own only a few satellites and must balance their intelligence value against the expense of building and running them.
Permission, not technology
For NATO's cyber and digital transformation chief, Jean-Charles Ellermann-Kingombe, the central question is how best to use AI. "The bottleneck is often not technology, but permission," he said, citing classification rules, national regulations and decisions about trust.
He said the alliance must make AI adoption possible at scale, with tools that are secure, interoperable and usable within NATO's infrastructure by personnel who understand both their strengths and their limits.
This story was prepared by the Hamasta Newsdesk with AI assistance, based on reporting by France 24. Read the original report. Photo: France 24.
More in International
See all
South Africa orders Musk's Starlink to stop unauthorised operations

US sounds out Ukraine on ceding Donetsk for NATO-style security guarantees

Russia reportedly demands NATO pull troops back to 1997 positions in Eastern Europe

Macron calls on Ukraine's allies to reopen debate on Kyiv joining NATO

Ukraine knocks out Kerch Bridge road span as Medvedev says 'no one needs Europe'







Global Community Remarks
0